Skip to content

Tenacious Gift Guide

Benny's picks for the 2025 holiday season! This is my selection of guaranteed successful holiday gifting for anyone in your life: kids, coworkers, family members. Something here for everyone, with price points starting under $10 going all the way up!

Filters

$
$
Lil Dumpster Fire 7-inch plush Plush 100soft
Lil Dumpster Fire 7-inch plush Plush 100soft Sold out

Lil Dumpster Fire 7-inch plush

$ 25.00
$ 25.00 - $ 25.00
$ 25.00
$ 19.00
$ 19.00 - $ 19.00
$ 19.00
Out of stock

Everything is still a waking nightmare, but you can comfort yourself with this lil Dumpster Fire plushie. Hide what you don't want to see in the se...

View full details
$ 25.00
$ 25.00 - $ 25.00
$ 25.00
$ 19.00
$ 19.00 - $ 19.00
$ 19.00
Sold out
Uglydoll Trunko plush Plush Uglydoll Sold out

Uglydoll Trunko plush

$ 19.99 - $ 19.99
$ 19.99
$ 19.99 - $ 19.99
$ 19.99
Out of stock

Trunko is over the top. He freaks out over everything and overreacting is his hobby.When the chips are down, he orders a million more chips at whol...

View full details
$ 19.99 - $ 19.99
$ 19.99
$ 19.99 - $ 19.99
$ 19.99
Sold out
PEANUTS SNOOPY HEAD Cream Corduroy 2" Keychain Plush Plush Bon Ton
PEANUTS SNOOPY HEAD Cream Corduroy 2" Keychain Plush Plush Bon Ton

PEANUTS SNOOPY HEAD Cream Corduroy 2" Keychain Plush

$ 19.99 - $ 19.99
$ 19.99
$ 19.99 - $ 19.99
$ 19.99
Only 3 left!

This collection pays homage to the world-renowned beagle, Snoopy, who now proudly graces the Bon Ton Toys Wall of Fame. Alongside him, we introduce...

View full details
$ 19.99 - $ 19.99
$ 19.99
$ 19.99 - $ 19.99
$ 19.99
MIFFY Cotton Candy Rose Pink Plush Plush Bon Ton
MIFFY Cotton Candy Rose Pink Plush Plush Bon Ton

MIFFY Cotton Candy Rose Pink Plush

$ 30.00 - $ 30.00
$ 30.00
$ 30.00 - $ 30.00
$ 30.00
in stock

Miffy was first created by Dick Bruna in 1955, a timeless and instantly recognizable design. Miffy Corduroy is the perfect plush gift for new babie...

View full details
$ 30.00 - $ 30.00
$ 30.00
$ 30.00 - $ 30.00
$ 30.00
MIFFY Standing Blue Dress plush Plush Bon Ton
MIFFY Standing Blue Dress plush Plush Bon Ton

MIFFY Standing Blue Dress plush

$ 30.00 - $ 30.00
$ 30.00
$ 30.00 - $ 30.00
$ 30.00
in stock

Miffy was first created by Dick Bruna in 1955, a timeless and instantly recognizable design. Miffy Corduroy is the perfect plush gift for new babie...

View full details
$ 30.00 - $ 30.00
$ 30.00
$ 30.00 - $ 30.00
$ 30.00
PEANUTS Snoopy Camper Van 11-inch Pillow Plush Plush Bon Ton
PEANUTS Snoopy Camper Van 11-inch Pillow Plush Plush Bon Ton

PEANUTS Snoopy Camper Van 11-inch Pillow Plush

$ 44.99 - $ 44.99
$ 44.99
$ 44.99 - $ 44.99
$ 44.99
in stock

This collection pays homage to the world-renowned beagle, Snoopy, who now proudly graces the Bon Ton Toys Wall of Fame. Alongside him, we introduce...

View full details
$ 44.99 - $ 44.99
$ 44.99
$ 44.99 - $ 44.99
$ 44.99
PEANUTS Retro 1950s Comic Strip 7-inch Snoopy Plush Plush Bon Ton
PEANUTS Retro 1950s Comic Strip 7-inch Snoopy Plush Plush Bon Ton

PEANUTS Retro 1950s Comic Strip 7-inch Snoopy Plush

$ 34.99 - $ 34.99
$ 34.99
$ 34.99 - $ 34.99
$ 34.99
in stock

This collection pays homage to the world-renowned beagle, Snoopy, who now proudly graces the Bon Ton Toys Wall of Fame. Alongside him, we introduce...

View full details
$ 34.99 - $ 34.99
$ 34.99
$ 34.99 - $ 34.99
$ 34.99
MIFFY Standing with Pumpkin Dress 9.5-inch Plush Plush Bon Ton
MIFFY Standing with Pumpkin Dress 9.5-inch Plush Plush Bon Ton

MIFFY Standing with Pumpkin Dress 9.5-inch Plush

$ 29.99 - $ 29.99
$ 29.99
$ 29.99 - $ 29.99
$ 29.99
in stock

Miffy was first created by Dick Bruna in 1955, a timeless and instantly recognizable design. Miffy Corduroy is the perfect plush gift for new babie...

View full details
$ 29.99 - $ 29.99
$ 29.99
$ 29.99 - $ 29.99
$ 29.99